I always, for the most part, read more than one book at a time. I do not know why this is. It is just a habit that I have formed over the last six years or so. For the last week, I have only been reading Mark Dever’s The Deliberate Church. Last night, at the behest of my brother, I started reading George Barna’s Revolution. Now, before I comment and quote, let me first inform you that while I read more than one book at a time, I usually try not to evaluate one upon the other. I believe that each book should rightly receive its own evaluation. However, these two books come from entirely different ends of the spectrum, or at least from my unfinished perspective.
The back story is that Barna shows that these "revolutionaries" are not typically associated with a local church. Indeed, the very reason that they are a revolutionary is that they are dissatisfied with the local church and opt for a more biblical "First Century Christianity," according to Barna. Compare these quotes….
Barna says this, so far:
Know this: just as the prophets of old were unwelcome in their own hometown, so are the Revolutionaries looked at askance by even their closest friends and family members. The skepticism of those who lead conventional spiritual lives is a palpable reminder that growth always comes with a price tag.
Be forewarned: just as Jesus Christ, the ultimate lover of humanity, was scorned, misunderstood, persecuted, and eventually murdered for His extreme love, goodness, compassion, humility, wisdom, and grace, so are Revolutionaries abused by a culture that is itself in crisis. The mere presence of Revolutionaries makes the American citizen - yes, even the typical churchgoer - uncomfortable. It is not uncommon for Revolutionaries to meet with rejection - verbal, intellectual, relational, or experiential - simply because of their determination to honor the God they love.Â
Now, I am not so sure that this is characteristic of biblical Christianity. Now, before I am stoned, let me explain myself. I agree, whole-heartedly, that we are to be like Christ, in all areas of life. We are to be compassionate, humble, wise in the Cross, displayers of grace and mercy. I believe that we should serve our neighbor and in so doing, serve our God. I agree that our whole life is to be a spiritual act of service to God.
Where I disagree is that if we are doing this, or attempting to do this, apart from a local church, then we are not being biblical about our service. Christ intended for us to be servants, but as a part of His Church whom He has entrusted with His gospel!Â
For anyone with a copy of Dever’s The Deliberate Church, I would refer you to chapter 4 "Taking in New Members." This is where Dever explains the demand and reasoning for church membership. There are numerous quotes that I could insert from Dever’s book here….but I will not.Â
Very rarely do I "rant" on this blog. I try to refrain. But maybe one reason that we have a bunch of people dissatisfied with local church activity is that too much of our culture and not enough of the gospel is ingrained. Those may sound like harsh words but let me further explain them. The very idea of "getting along with others in the context of church," is to experience grace and forgiveness as God has shown us. It is also to display God’s glory through the covenants as we, the local church, covenant together for the purpose of displaying God’s glory.Â
Barna would say, thus far, again I am not through the book, that Jesus was a revolutionary. He was. We are called to be. But I don’t think Jesus would commission us apart from His Church whom He entrusted with His good news. These "revolutionaries," in my opinion, need to re-evaluate their true reasoning for separation from the Church. If there is not a "good enough one," serve to His glory to make it that way or, if determined by God, start one that does glorify Him……but do not serve apart from the Church; do not live your own life without "organized religion."Â
I will end this rant for now. I must even be fair and say that my opinion might change in the years to come. I would be the first to admit that. But anything that negates the role and function of God’s church, I think, is not what God would intend His children to do.